root
12 KiB
Operation Delay Drift Adjudication Ledger
Immutable spec path: /root/projects/resister-codex/codex-oauth-automation-extension-upstream-base-vu7.3/codex-oauth-automation-extension/.worktrees/feature-operation-delay-ultra73/docs/superpowers/specs/2026-05-07-operation-delay-design.md
Immutable plan path: /root/projects/resister-codex/codex-oauth-automation-extension-upstream-base-vu7.3/codex-oauth-automation-extension/.worktrees/feature-operation-delay-ultra73/docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-07-operation-delay-plan.md
Controller-only mutation rule: only the P9/controller may create, append, supersede, close, summarize, or otherwise mutate this ledger. Subagents may read it, cite DRIFT_ID, report evidence, and request supersession, but may not edit it directly.
Active Adjudications Summary
| DRIFT_ID | STATUS | SCOPE | P9_FINAL_ADJUDICATION | EFFECTIVE_EXECUTION_CONTRACT |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DRIFT-2026-05-08-T2-001 | ACTIVE | Task 2 sidepanel switch copy | PLAN_DRIFT_CONTINUE_SAFE | Use sidepanel switch copy that communicates input, selection, click, submit, continue, authorization, and 2 seconds; do not regress to the narrower frozen-plan snippet. |
| DRIFT-2026-05-08-T3-001 | ACTIVE | Task 3 2925 provider metadata test scope | PLAN_DRIFT_CONTINUE_SAFE | Treat tests/background-icloud-mail-provider.test.js as in scope for Task 3 checkpoint because it asserts the 2925 provider metadata changed by the required operation-delay injection. |
| DRIFT-2026-05-08-T4-001 | ACTIVE | Task 4 Step 3 direct-complete test scope | PLAN_DRIFT_CONTINUE_SAFE | Treat tests/step3-direct-complete.test.js as in scope for Task 4 checkpoint because it verifies Step 3 completion-before-navigation plus deferred password-submit operation-delay behavior. |
| DRIFT-2026-05-08-T7-001 | ACTIVE | Task 7 mail-2925 full-suite harness scope | PLAN_DRIFT_CONTINUE_SAFE | Treat tests/mail-2925-content.test.js as in scope for Task 7 only for a narrow stale-harness fix providing performOperationWithDelay to the existing ensureAgreementChecked harness. |
DRIFT-2026-05-08-T2-001
DRIFT_ID: DRIFT-2026-05-08-T2-001
STATUS: ACTIVE
SUPERSEDES_DRIFT_ID: NONE
SUPERSEDED_BY_DRIFT_ID: NONE
SCOPE: Task 2 sidepanel switch copy
TRIGGER: Task 2 spec reviewer reported that the frozen Task 2 Step 3 HTML copy snippet omitted required operation categories while the implementation used spec-complete copy.
FROZEN_PLAN_STEP: docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-07-operation-delay-plan.md:330-348, especially line 337 title copy and line 344 caption copy.
GOVERNING_SPEC_REQUIREMENT: docs/superpowers/specs/2026-05-07-operation-delay-design.md:36-38 requires the sidepanel boolean operation-delay switch label to communicate waits after page input, selection, click, submit, continue, and authorization operations.
REPO_OR_WORKTREE_EVIDENCE: sidepanel/sidepanel.html:578-589 implements the switch; line 582 title copy and line 589 visible caption copy cover input, selection, click, submit, continue, authorization, and 2 seconds.
INVESTIGATOR_JUDGMENTS: Two fresh read-only investigators returned PLAN_DRIFT_CONTINUE_SAFE. Investigator 1 found the implementation aligned with the immutable spec and literal frozen-plan copy would under-satisfy the spec. Investigator 2 found Task 2 Step 3's literal HTML snippet not executable as written for the copy requirement, while the rest of Task 2 remains safely executable.
P9_FINAL_ADJUDICATION: PLAN_DRIFT_CONTINUE_SAFE
EFFECTIVE_EXECUTION_CONTRACT: For Task 2 and later reviews, treat the immutable spec's all-six-category sidepanel switch copy requirement as controlling. Preserve copy that communicates input, selection, click, submit, continue, authorization, and 2 seconds. Do not request or implement a regression to the narrower frozen-plan snippet.
SAFE_TO_CONTINUE: YES
REOPEN_ONLY_IF: New immutable spec evidence changes the sidepanel switch copy requirement, or repo evidence shows the implementation no longer communicates all six operation categories and the 2 second duration.
DRIFT-2026-05-08-T3-001
DRIFT_ID: DRIFT-2026-05-08-T3-001
STATUS: ACTIVE
SUPERSEDES_DRIFT_ID: NONE
SUPERSEDED_BY_DRIFT_ID: NONE
SCOPE: Task 3 2925 provider metadata test scope
TRIGGER: Task 3 spec reviewer reported that the frozen Task 3 file list and commit step omitted tests/background-icloud-mail-provider.test.js, but full-suite verification required updating that existing 2925 provider metadata expectation after the required 2925 operation-delay injection change.
FROZEN_PLAN_STEP: docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-07-operation-delay-plan.md:421-431 lists Task 3 files and tests without tests/background-icloud-mail-provider.test.js; docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-07-operation-delay-plan.md:656-660 gives a Task 3 commit step that also omits that test file.
GOVERNING_SPEC_REQUIREMENT: docs/superpowers/specs/2026-05-07-operation-delay-design.md:16-22, 44-52, and 80-83 require covered page operations to use the centralized content-side operation delay gate and current enabled state, while excluding only disabled/background/excluded work.
REPO_OR_WORKTREE_EVIDENCE: background.js:11173-11180 implements the 2925 provider reuse metadata with content/utils.js, content/operation-delay.js, and content/mail-2925.js in order. background/mail-2925-session.js:32-36 implements the matching session injection order. tests/background-icloud-mail-provider.test.js:140-152 is an existing assertion over the same 2925 provider metadata and must expect content/operation-delay.js for the full suite to remain aligned. npm test passed 817/817 with that update.
INVESTIGATOR_JUDGMENTS: Two fresh read-only investigators returned PLAN_DRIFT_CONTINUE_SAFE. Both found the frozen plan's 2925 production requirement spec-correct, but the file list and commit step incomplete because they omitted an existing metadata test naturally affected by the required background.js provider metadata change.
P9_FINAL_ADJUDICATION: PLAN_DRIFT_CONTINUE_SAFE
EFFECTIVE_EXECUTION_CONTRACT: For Task 3 and later reviews, treat tests/background-icloud-mail-provider.test.js as in scope. Include it in the Task 3 checkpoint commit with the frozen Task 3 files. Preserve 2925 injection order as content/utils.js, content/operation-delay.js, content/mail-2925.js in both provider reuse and Mail2925 session paths. Do not treat this test update as unrelated scope creep.
SAFE_TO_CONTINUE: YES
REOPEN_ONLY_IF: New repo evidence shows tests/background-icloud-mail-provider.test.js no longer asserts the 2925 provider metadata changed by Task 3, or immutable spec evidence removes the 2925/provider reuse operation-delay injection need.
DRIFT-2026-05-08-T4-001
DRIFT_ID: DRIFT-2026-05-08-T4-001
STATUS: ACTIVE
SUPERSEDES_DRIFT_ID: NONE
SUPERSEDED_BY_DRIFT_ID: NONE
SCOPE: Task 4 Step 3 direct-complete test scope
TRIGGER: Task 4 spec reviewer reported that the frozen Task 4 file list and commit step omitted tests/step3-direct-complete.test.js, but Step 3 operation-delay migration must preserve the existing completion-before-navigation contract while routing the deferred password submit through the operation-delay gate.
FROZEN_PLAN_STEP: docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-07-operation-delay-plan.md:667-674 lists Task 4 files and tests without tests/step3-direct-complete.test.js; docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-07-operation-delay-plan.md:788-790 gives a Task 4 commit step that also omits that test file.
GOVERNING_SPEC_REQUIREMENT: docs/superpowers/specs/2026-05-07-operation-delay-design.md:18-20, 44-52, 55-60, and 80-83 require covered page fills/submits/continues to use the centralized content-side operation delay gate. docs/superpowers/specs/2026-05-07-operation-delay-design.md:111 makes data/step-definitions.js canonical for step keys, and data/step-definitions.js:14 defines Step 3 as fill-password.
REPO_OR_WORKTREE_EVIDENCE: content/signup-page.js:2463-2580 implements step3_fillEmailPassword; content/signup-page.js:2533-2536 routes password fill through performOperationWithDelay; content/signup-page.js:2559 reports Step 3 completion before deferred submit navigation; content/signup-page.js:2561-2570 routes the deferred password submit through performOperationWithDelay. tests/step3-direct-complete.test.js:54-235 verifies completion-before-navigation and deferred submit operation-delay behavior. Targeted verification including this test passed 38/38.
INVESTIGATOR_JUDGMENTS: Two fresh read-only investigators returned PLAN_DRIFT_CONTINUE_SAFE. Both found the frozen plan's broad Task 4 requirement covers Step 3 signup-page operations, but its exact file list and commit step are incomplete because they omit an existing regression test materially affected by the required content/signup-page.js change.
P9_FINAL_ADJUDICATION: PLAN_DRIFT_CONTINUE_SAFE
EFFECTIVE_EXECUTION_CONTRACT: For Task 4 and later reviews, treat tests/step3-direct-complete.test.js as in scope. Include it in the Task 4 checkpoint commit with the frozen Task 4 files. Preserve Step 3 completion/report before the deferred navigation-prone submit, and keep both password fill and deferred password submit routed through the shared operation-delay gate.
SAFE_TO_CONTINUE: YES
REOPEN_ONLY_IF: New repo evidence shows tests/step3-direct-complete.test.js no longer asserts Step 3 direct-completion behavior affected by Task 4, or immutable spec evidence removes Step 3 password fill/submit from covered OpenAI/auth page operations.
DRIFT-2026-05-08-T7-001
DRIFT_ID: DRIFT-2026-05-08-T7-001
STATUS: ACTIVE
SUPERSEDES_DRIFT_ID: NONE
SUPERSEDED_BY_DRIFT_ID: NONE
SCOPE: Task 7 mail-2925 full-suite harness scope
TRIGGER: Task 7 implementer reported that targeted docs/exclusion tests passed but full npm test failed in tests/mail-2925-content.test.js because its extracted ensureAgreementChecked harness did not provide the new performOperationWithDelay dependency introduced by the spec-correct Task 6 content/mail-2925.js operation-delay wrapping.
FROZEN_PLAN_STEP: docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-07-operation-delay-plan.md:1031-1039 lists Task 7 files and full existing test verification but omits tests/mail-2925-content.test.js; docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-07-operation-delay-plan.md:1107-1115 requires full npm test to pass; docs/superpowers/plans/2026-05-07-operation-delay-plan.md:1117-1121 gives a Task 7 commit step that omits that harness file.
GOVERNING_SPEC_REQUIREMENT: docs/superpowers/specs/2026-05-07-operation-delay-design.md:18-22, 44-52, 53-62, and 80-83 require covered page clicks/submits/controls to use the centralized content-side operation delay gate, while 64-71 excludes polling/background work, not 2925 login/session UI clicks.
REPO_OR_WORKTREE_EVIDENCE: content/mail-2925.js:490-512 has ensureAgreementChecked() calling performOperationWithDelay for checkbox clicks, content/mail-2925.js:1057-1060 defines that helper, and content/mail-2925.js:1144 calls ensureAgreementChecked() from ensureMail2925Session(). tests/mail-2925-content.test.js:896-902 extracts ensureAgreementChecked without extracting or stubbing performOperationWithDelay, causing node --test tests/mail-2925-content.test.js to fail 14/1 and full npm test to fail 841/1.
INVESTIGATOR_JUDGMENTS: Two fresh read-only investigators returned PLAN_DRIFT_CONTINUE_SAFE. Both found the production content/mail-2925.js change spec-correct and the failure a narrow stale test harness issue. Both found Task 7's full-suite requirement makes the harness update necessary despite omission from the frozen Task 7 file list and commit step.
P9_FINAL_ADJUDICATION: PLAN_DRIFT_CONTINUE_SAFE
EFFECTIVE_EXECUTION_CONTRACT: For Task 7 and later reviews, treat tests/mail-2925-content.test.js as in scope only for a narrow stale-harness fix that provides or extracts performOperationWithDelay for the existing ensureAgreementChecked test. Include that test update in the Task 7 checkpoint. Do not change runtime content/mail-2925.js, do not remove operation-delay wrapping from 2925 session UI, and do not wrap polling/cleanup handlers.
SAFE_TO_CONTINUE: YES
REOPEN_ONLY_IF: New evidence shows tests/mail-2925-content.test.js no longer exercises ensureAgreementChecked, or immutable spec evidence removes 2925 login/session UI checkbox clicks from covered operation-delay behavior.